Submitting a buylist requires you to be logged in, please create an account or log in
Selling cards to MythicMTG.com is fast and easy. You will need to login to submit a buylist.
To use the web submission form, scroll down and simply fill in the qty you wish to sell of each card below, your contact information, and submit the form.
We will respond within 24 hours with our approval to ship the cards.
Once approved, ship the cards to us:
52025 State Road 933
South Bend, IN 46637
We must receive the cards within 8 days of approval, or reserve the right to refuse the buy order. Please don’t submit buy orders for cards you’re not immediately ready to send.
Read full terms and conditions
Make sure to insure the package and get delivery confirmation as we are not responsible for cards lost in the mail.
Condition: The prices listed are for near mint/unplayed cards. Currently it is our desire to only buy near mint cards.
In some cases, ( cards we are paying more than $30 for) we may accept cards of lesser condition with the following deductions:
Slightly played: 80% of the listed value
Moderately Played: 60% of the listed value
Heavy play and damaged cards will be returned. WE also reserve the right to return SP and MP cards. You will be contacted before we Issue payment if your buy order will include returns.
You should email ahead of time if your submission will include lesser condition cards to ensure we will accept them.
Store credit placed on your account within 48 hours of receipt.
Paypal made within 48 hours of receipt.
Check mailed within 72 hours of receipt.
Questions about our buylist should be sent to Mythicmtgsales@gmail.com